The Crafter’s Guide To Choosing The Ideal Sweater Yarn For Sweaters

By Jodie Morgan

| Last Updated:

Making a yarn sweater is no small feat. However, with the perfect yarn, it’s an endeavor that yields a rewarding sense of achievement and, of course, a cozy, warm sweater too. Let’s help you select the ideal yarn for your next sweater-making journey.

Img Of Pastel And Warm Color Yarns In A Metal Bowl

Note: If you click a link on this page, and make a purchase, I may receive a commission but at no extra cost to you. Learn More

Don't Know What To Knit Next?

Banish your knitting dilemmas: discover your next masterpiece in just 7 mins. Get 12 hand-curated designs, 6 invaluable tips, and 6 pieces of inspiring knitting art delivered to you every Tuesday.

What To Consider In Fibers For Making Sweaters

Seasonality Of Sweater Yarn: What To Knit Or Crochet With

A crucial consideration in your yarn selection process, is the season for which you’re crafting your garment. For those chilly winter months, I’ve always favored merino wool worsted, a natural fiber known for its plush feel, durability, and gentle caress against the skin, making it a more comfortable alternative to other sheep’s wool varieties.

As we move into summer, a unique set of considerations comes into play. Plant-based fibers like cotton, silk, or linen are your go-to options for summer garments. They’re cooler and perfect for the heat, but they stretch more easily than fibers suitable for winter.

Synthetic fibers like acrylic and polyester may be lighter on the wallet which is important to consider when making hand knitted sweaters, although they might not breathe or endure as well.

Here’ a breakdown of the different options.

Wool is a classic choice for sweater knitting, renowned for its warmth, resilience, and excellent stitch definition. Different sheep breeds offer diverse types of yarn wool with unique characteristics. For instance, a more rustic breed like Shetland wool is good for textured stitch patterns and colorwork.

Wool tends to felt, so handle your wool yarn gently and avoid excessive agitation when washing your finished piece. Consider how the natural elasticity of wool may affect your sweater’s fit and drape. This quality can make wool garments comfortable and forgiving.

Acrylic yarn is a popular choice for sweater knitting, appreciated for its cost-effectiveness, light weight, and ease of care. Opt for high-quality acrylic yarn with a soft feel and good drape to enhance the comfort of your finished piece. They’re the best choice for a baby sweater.

Acrylic yarn doesn’t have the same elasticity as natural fibers like wool. This means tightly knit stitches won’t recover their shape easily.

Simpler stitch patterns often work best with acrylic. Also, blocking acrylic yarn is called the process of “killing.” It evens out stitches and improves the drape of your garment, but the effect is irreversible.

Choosing yarn blends for knitting sweaters can combine the best qualities of various fibers. Are you seeking warmth, breathability, or a luxurious feel? Blends often include wool for warmth and elasticity, cotton for breathability and softness, or silk for elegance and sheen. Each blend behaves differently. Care requirements also differ; some may be machine washable, while others require hand washing.

For a unique spin on your next yarn knitting or crochet sweater project, consider fibers like alpaca or bamboo. Each brings unique qualities that can make your sweater a standout piece. Alpaca the yarn fiber, known for its luxurious softness, is perfect for cozy sweaters, while bamboo provides lightweight, breathable options that are great for warmer weather garments.

Care & Maintenance Of Your Sweater Yarns

I opt for handwashing my knitted pieces to preserve their longevity. However, if you’re one for convenience, using the washing machine and dryer is a godsend, especially for heavier sweaters. Acrylic yarns tick the box for effortless care while natural fibers need more TLC.

The Right Yarn Weight Matters

Choosing the right yarn weight can be the difference between a knitting success story and a bulky yarn disaster. Fingering or fine weight yarn is a reliable choice, offering the right thickness for your sweater project. Newbies might find it too intricate to handle, so experimenting with sport or DK weight yarn is a suitable alternative.

Remember, heavier weights yield well-structured garments, but they may compromise on the drape. Bulky sweaters may have that high-fashion look, but they’re a challenge to make and cumbersome to wear unless you’re combating frosty, cold weather often.

The golden rule is to adhere to the recommended yarn weight specified in your pattern.

Coloring Your Sweater World With Lovely Wool

For color choices, it’s all about intended use. I’m drawn to bold, vibrant colors because there’s something uplifting about the mix of warmth and bright hues during the colder months. However, neutral tones can bring a classic, timeless elegance to your creation.

If you’re knitting for children, consider using durable and machine-washable acrylic yarn in a color they adore. Remember, if you’re buying dye lotted yarn, purchase all same yarn you need at once because colors vary between different dye lots.

Determining The Yardage

Don’t underestimate the amount of yarn you’ll need for your sweater! It’s easy to fall short, as I did during my sweater knit initial endeavors. It’s best to have some extra on hand, particularly for beginners who might need to rectify a few errors along the way.

Once you’ve settled on your pattern and calculated the yarn weights and necessary yardage, get all the yarn you need in a single purchase to avoid the annoying wait for additional yarn deliveries.

Budgeting For Knitting Or Crocheting A Sweater

Knitting a sweater requires a considerable amount of yarn, and the costs add up. While “budget” or “value” yarns might tempt, they often compromise on quality and longevity. Given the investment of time and skill a sweater requires, opt for a premium yarn that’s built to last. A blend of acrylic and wool provides a cost-effective compromise. You can sometimes find online sales for a discount off the original price.

Picking Patterns: The Look You’re Aiming For

There’s an immense joy in scrolling through Pinterest and Ravelry in search of the ideal DIY crochet or knitting patterns for your sweater. With a seemingly endless array of designs for knits and crochet items available, your next knitting adventure is a click away.

When choosing your yarn, balance softness and durability. Super soft yarn feels wonderful, but it might not withstand the test of time. In contrast, durable yarns are long-lasting, but they may not offer the same comfort. Single-ply yarns are softer but don’t have the same longevity as plied yarns.

The structure of your sweater is vital, and animal fibers usually maintain their shape better than plant fibers.

Choosing Yarn Based On The Sweater Style

Before diving into your yarn selection, it’s crucial to consider the style of your sweater. If you’re making a chunky cabled sweater, opt for a robust, warm yarn. Lightweight lace designs require a more delicate, airy fiber.

Intricate patterns like cables or textured stitches work well with smooth, plied yarn to highlight the stitchwork. On the flip side, a simple stockinette pullover might benefit from a luxurious, haloed yarn like mohair or alpaca.

Oversized or relaxed-fit knit sweaters may call for lightweight yarn to maintain the garment’s shape without becoming too hefty or bulky.

Sizing and Measurements

Ensure you double-check measurements such as the bust/chest, arm, and torso before deciding on the yarn quantity. Achieving the perfect fit needs a gauge swatch prior to starting your project. This square of knitting helps you determine if your stitch and row counts align with the pattern’s specifications.

Another useful tip is to refer to the pattern’s detailed measurements for each size. Measure yourself or the intended wearer and compare these with the schematic. Consider any desired modifications, like adding extra length to sleeves or body, or adjusting the fit for a more tailored or relaxed look. Different yarns and fibers behave differently regarding drape.

Now you’re all knowledged up about sweater yarns! Choosing the right yarn will be a breeze and you’ll have a sweater you adore.

Don't Know What To Knit Next?

Banish your knitting dilemmas: discover your next masterpiece in just 7 mins. Get 12 hand-curated designs, 6 invaluable tips, and 6 pieces of inspiring knitting art delivered to you every Tuesday.

Leave a Comment