Making A Yarn Scarf: A Scarf Yarn Guide For Crafting Gorgeous Scarves

By Jodie Morgan

| Last Updated:

Crafting a yarn scarf is great fun, but it can be challenging for choosing the ideal yarn. You might picture the perfect scarf in your mind, but are uncertain about the yarn fiber you need to bring it to life. I’ve got some essential tips on selecting the perfect yarn for scarves.

Img Of Balls Of Yarn In A Woven Basket In Soft Lighting

Note: If you click a link on this page, and make a purchase, I may receive a commission but at no extra cost to you. Learn More

Frustrated Teacher Quits In Disgust, Sells The Farm, Moves The Family Halfway Across The World And… Starts Knitting

Factors To Consider When Choosing Scarf Yarn

Before you set out on your yarn expedition, here are some factors to contemplate. This list should help you make a well-informed decision for the right yarn for your scarf’s project.

Yarns Care Requirements For Your Scarf

Not all yarns are created equal, especially with their care requirements. Some yarns demand hand-washing, while others can brave the washing machine. If your schedule is already jam-packed, and you can’t afford the time for hand-washing soft yarn, opt for machine-washable yarns.

If you’re giving the scarf as a gift, consider choosing an easy-care yarn.

The ball band tells you everything you need to know. Understanding yarn labels isn’t as mysterious as it might first appear. They’ll tell you the fiber content, yardage, recommended needle/hook size, and even a gauge (how many stitches and rows you should get over a set area). And, of course, they also have care instructions.

Yarn Material: Wool Yarn? Acrylic? Something Else?

The type of material your yarn is made of is perhaps the most crucial aspect to consider. Different yarn materials come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages. For instance, acrylic yarns are known for their durability and machine-washable nature, while wool offers a soft touch and excellent insulation. Consider your personal preferences and the end use of the scarf.

If you’re a beginner (scarves are the perfect project), get a fiber that can handle being “frogged” multiple times. “Frogging” means to undo your work or rip it out. It’s inevitable you’ll need to do this at least once, but it’s okay! If you’re not happy with how your project is turning out, it’s perfectly fine to start over. Every mistake is a learning opportunity.

Scarf Yarns Texture

A smooth scarf is always a classic choice and is the best option for beginners. But if you’ve had practice, have you ever considered a fuzzy or bumpy yarn for pizazz? Yarn texture adds an extra layer of visual and tactile intrigue to your yarn DIY crochet scarf. Mixing and matching textures in one project leads to a true one-of-a-kind creation.


You’ll put your heart and soul into this scarf, so it needs to withstand the test of time (and the occasional coffee spill). Some acrylic yarn resists pilling and takes everyday wear and tear in stride. Perfect for a handmade scarf, that’s going to be a regular in your wardrobe rotation.

Natural fibers like knitting wool or cotton aren’t as resistant to pilling as their synthetic counterparts, but they make up for it with their natural warmth and breathability. Sometimes, wool is treated to improve pilling resistance.


This is an accessory that’s close to your skin, so softness is paramount. If you’re looking for cloud-like softness, turn to merino wool blends, cashmere, or high-quality acrylic yarns.


Some yarns, like our good friend cotton, have the wonderful ability to “bloom” or expand when washed. This bloom gives your scarf extra volume and a luxurious drape that screams sophistication. Just remember to factor in the bloom when you’re planning the dimensions of your scarf, because a blooming cotton yarn really could make your scarf larger than you initially planned.


Moving on to “memory” – and no, we’re not talking about the ability to recall last summer’s vacation. In yarn speak, memory refers to how well the yarn holds its shape. Yarns with good memory, like our resilient wool, maintain their shape and drape.

Yarns with low memory are more relaxed. They give you a lightweight scarf that becomes misshapen more easily. Don’t worry – with care, they can still make fabulous scarves.

Blocking Your Crochet Or Knitting Patterns

Some yarns, especially natural fibers like cotton, can benefit from a process called blocking to help them achieve their ideal shape and drape. This involves gently stretching and pinning the scarf into shape as it dries. Not all yarns need to be blocked, but for those that do, it’s a great way to show them some extra love.


This is all about how tightly the yarn’s fibers are spiraled together. More twisted yarns create a denser fabric, which is like a warm, snug hug around your neck. Loosely twisted yarns have more drape.

Allergen Resistance

If you’ve got allergies or sensitive skin, you’ll want to consider yarn brand for allergen resistance. Many acrylic yarns and treated wool yarns (think superwash wool) are more resistant to allergens.

Yarn Yardage

Always check the label for how many yards (or meters) are in each skein of worsted weight yarn or any other type. Nobody wants to be left hanging in the middle of a project because they underestimated their yarn needs. It’s always safer to overestimate a bit when buying yarn.

Choosing A Yarn Weight For Scarves

The weight of your yarn directly influences the gauge (number of stitches per inch) of your scarf. A heavier yarn leads to a thicker scarf, and lighter weight yarns results in a thinner scarf. For a quick project, chunky or bulky yarn is perfect and creates a warm, fluffy scarf. If you want a warm scarf with something lighter or more delicate, try a DK or fingering weight yarn. Knitting patterns will have recommendations.

What Color Do You Want To Use?

Remember to consider color and patterns! Scarves are a fantastic way to play with color, whether it’s a vibrant, multicolored crochet or knitting yarn that does all the colorwork for you or a mix of solid colors you’ve chosen yourself. Darker colors are more forgiving for beginners, as they hide uneven stitches better than light colors, but it’s more difficult to see the stitch pattern.

Your Budget

Current Yarn prices can vary widely. Determine how much you’re comfortable spending on your scarf project before you set out to shop. This can save you from impulse buys that could dent your wallet.

With the perfect scarf yarn choice you’ll be ready to choose a favorite pattern, and begin crafting a cozy scarf to keep you or someone special warm for years to come.


Now you’re equipped with the info to pick the perfect yarn for your scarf! With all these yarn choices, you’ll make the ideal selection for your project. 

Frustrated Teacher Quits In Disgust, Sells The Farm, Moves The Family Halfway Across The World And… Starts Knitting

Leave a Comment